Stop Buying These 10 Cards If You Want to Flip for Profit
What’s the fastest way to make more money flipping cards? Most people say “find better cards to buy.”
Bzzzzz… close, but not quite. The fastest way is to stop buying the wrong ones. Even after I started stacking wins, I wasn’t profitable for a while, because I kept spending money on cards I’d now never flip under any conditions.
Once I stopped buying those types of cards, my percentage of wins and overall profitability went way up.
Here are 10 cards that I avoid for flipping:
1. Custom or Fan-Made Cards
Now, if I told you:
“Hey someone made this card on their computer and now they’re selling it on eBay….”
You probably know that’s not an investable card. It’s just not always that obvious.
As long as you’re looking up comps and checking price history, it’s pretty easy to notice if a card isn’t an officially licensed one.
2. Unlicensed Cards
These are cards made by legit companies, but they don’t have the license to include team names/logos.
The cards look…off when they have to airbrush logos off jerseys:

Not only are they cheaper, but they don’t hold value as well either. Much smaller market of interested buyers also makes them harder to sell
(Autos can sometimes be an exception, like for Wemby because he didn’t have licensed autos that year… but the rule still stands in almost every case)
3. College or No-Logo Draft Cards
When pro uniform cards come out, the college stuff plummets in value.
I’m curious now that Bowman is a licensed product for the NFL, if college football cards will start to do better… but for now, stay away.
Similarly, I once bought a LaMelo Prizm Draft Picks rookie upon release. He didn’t play college, so the card just had his name, and he was wearing a plain black shirt. Needless to say, the card dropped by 80% within a month.
4. Signed Cards Not Officially Released by the Brand
Say you get a card of Cooper Flagg, you show up at a Mavs game, and you’re able to have him sign it.
That would be amazing!
However, don’t expect it to carry the same value as if it were a part of an official autograph set released by Topps.
Forgeries, including the certificates of authentication, have been a rampant problem. This makes buyers wary. Plus, a random signed card doesn’t have comps, so you can’t really have any idea what it’s supposed to sell for.
5. First Year of a Set
The whole point of short-term flips (which I define as 3-6 months) is that you need the card to go up in value.
But with a newly released set, you have no idea the long-term viability of it!
Sometimes new sets come out with hype and it dies off. Sometimes they come out flat to begin with because Topps (or whoever) did a bad job.
It’s true that sometimes we get Cosmic Chrome that really takes off and becomes a mainstay, but there are too many variables to make investing in a new set worth it.
6. Cards in Non-PSA Slabs
I get asked ALL the time:
“What about XYZ grading company? They have this newfangled tech and their slabs look great!”
And the only thing I’ll say back is:
“Okay, but what’s the resale value?”
For flipping cards, I never ever dabble in anything except PSA. They’re not my favorite slab (I much prefer SGC), but the values just aren’t there.
Plus, volume is much lower, making comps hard.
I know you might wish another company takes over the top spot, but predicting what that will be and investing in those cards isn’t sustainable investing.
7. Digital Cards
For a minute, digital cards were hot, and I’m ashamed to say I spent a chunk of change on these!
But they mostly went by the wayside, so don’t get sucked into these.
I always wonder how often the people buying listings like these realize they’re digital before it’s too late?

8. Cards Priced at All-Time Highs
Like, no duh, right?
It’s probably the single most common mistake I see in the hobby!
This is how it happens:
You love how player A is playing
You look up his recent comps on eBay
You buy a card around that price
That’s how most people buy…
The problem is, you have no idea if pricing has already skyrocketed!
For a profitable flip, you need price to go up 30%+.
If pricing has already gone up significantly (which often happens on guys who are playing super well), then there’s much less room for you to profit.
You must look at price charts to understand the trend before you buy.
9. No Recent Sales
I don’t buy cards unless I have a good idea of what the card is actually worth in the moment.
For example, let’s say you want to buy a superstar’s auto numbered out of 10. There won’t be many sales of that card (if any).
So how do you know a fair price to buy it at?
Of course you can make money on cards like that, and plenty of people do, but I consider that an advanced strategy. There’s more than enough other cards out there with plenty of price history and comps.
10. Thick Relics
This one is purely for graders.
Thick relics are famously tough grades. They have such thick edges that there’s just a lot more surface area for things to go wrong. Plus, sometimes the edges of the card right next to the patch can get bent or dinged easily.
I typed in “National Treasures Patch” into Gem Rate (the site I use to see what percent of the time cards come back as a PSA 10).
Here’s what I found:

I don’t grade below 60%, yet none of the top 5 results are above 21%. I scrolled for pages and didn’t find any that hit my criteria.
Takeaways
You could summarize most of my rules into:
Don’t buy anything that hasn’t been proven many times over.
In other words, don’t speculate on new stuff. Don’t buy without comps. Don’t hope a new trend will take off and you’re the first.
I call that Buy & Pray.
Instead, month-over-month profit comes from investing in predictability. Not from losing 8 out of 10 and hoping the other 2 are crazy home runs that pay for the rest.
Any other types of cards you’d add to the list?
And We’re Done!
Before you go: Here’s how I can help…
1) Casual Flipper Bootcamp - 6 live training sessions designed to teach you to be a profitable sports card flipper. Join the waiting list now.
2) HCL Investor - My best investment plays each week, including cards, pricing, timeline windows, and more. Delivered every Saturday.
3) Cards to Cash - My entire investing strategy playbook, available on Amazon. It currently has 95+ reviews with a 4.8 rating.


