Sponsored by

The Riskiest Bet in the Hobby

Only invest in cards with a high probability of working out.

It seems stupidly obvious, but I’m here to tell you you’re probably not doing as well as you think at avoiding high-risk cards.

Maybe it’s hard to find the “home run” investments, so you compromise a little on your card purchases. Or, you want to root for a certain player, or a bunch of other reasons.

But none more so than injury-prone players.

Why “Injury-Prone” is the Worst Gamble in the hobby

It’s so tantalizing to invest in someone whose pricing is low because of injuries.

Take Embiid, for example. He’s one of the best scorers in NBA history. He’s actually the all-time leader in points per minute played!

With a fully healthy career, he could’ve been a top-10 all-time player. I truly believe that.

So year after year, people buy low, hoping he’ll figure out the injury thing…

The problem is, it rarely happens. Injuries either sap a player's top-end ability, or they’re just never available enough to matter… or both.

Guys who overcome chronic injuries to become All-Timers are so rare. I can think of maybe Steph Curry?

Let other people gamble their money.

Spotting Injury Prone (And Who’s Next?)

It’s easy to look back after someone’s career has been torpedoed by injuries…

There’s Zion Williamson, Joel Embiid, Tua Tagovailoa, Mike Trout, and others. (People forget Tua has been in MVP conversations).

And we know their hobby values tanked once it became clear they weren’t going to get “it” back.

Here’s Zion’s PSA 10 Prizm, which you can get for sub-$20:

But you already know this - you’re not buying Zion right now for flips because there’s no chance he returns to the all-world level he played at when healthy.

And there’s NO way people are buying Joel Embiid, right? Oh no…

That’s pure insanity to me, but LeBron and Jaylen Brown arriving to form a superteam gets people excited. Anyway, don’t go buy Embiid—he hasn’t played more than 40 games in any of the past 3 seasons.

Finding the Next Injury-Prone Players

I still doubt serious flippers are buying Embiid, since I’m guessing Philly PCers are propping up the price.

Here are some guys I’m either completely out on, or we’re getting close.

Jayden Daniels & Jaxson Dart

I hate seeing this for 2 young players. At least Daniels had his historical rookie season mostly healthy, but since then, he’s been repeatedly injured.

Jaxson Dart appears to be the kind of player not built for the NFL.

I’m telling you right now, many collectors are going to buy in on the injury lows because of the potential he’s shown.

He’s been knocked out of several games and is now likely out for the year. Nope.

Ronald Acuna Jr

He’s already had FIVE seasons playing less than 110 games. He’s tantalizing because his MVP season was so electric, but he’s had only TWO seasons in his career with WAR above 4.

He’s injury-prone and inconsistent - a combo I’m not investing in.

Giannis Antetokounmpo

He’s been relatively durable during the regular season until last year, but he’s been constantly injured at the end of seasons and into the playoffs.

Big guys who rely on scoring in the paint have a long history of tapering off around this age.

Joe Burrow

Did you know he’s played 10 games or less in half of his seasons?

He was a good offseason investment, but now that games have started, he’s historically been 50/50 with even-finishing seasons… so I’m staying away for now. I’d love for him to prove me wrong so we can see one of the game’s greats put together MVP runs… but I’m skeptical.

Kyler Murray

I know he’s not a star, but there’s a world where he has a Sam Darnold-like impact on a team with a great defense and wide receivers.

He should be good enough for that… if he wasn’t always injured.

Like Burrow, he’s more injury-prone than you think. In the previous 4 seasons, he only played more than 11 games once… and he’s already been injured this season.

Ja Morant & LaMelo Ball

Both are exciting players who’ve missed a ton of games in recent seasons. Morant has mostly been written off, and I’d urge you to resist the “buy low” temptation. I don’t think his redemption arc happens with the Blazers.

Same thing with LaMelo. He’s more highly regarded, but always injured. I don’t have any LaMelo right now, but the smart play is to watch for an immediate jolt to the Wolves and then sell him. I don’t trust him at all long term.

Others to Watch

These guys aren’t there… yet.

  • Lamar Jackson - never seriously injured, but always seems to miss 3-4 games

  • Aaron Judge - missed significant chunks of 5 seasons

  • Victor Wembanyama - I’m not worried about the blood clot issue from 2024, but NBA history says guys his size will likely be injury-prone. Still great short-term flip potential, but I wouldn’t spend good money on a long-term hold.

  • Dare I say it… Shohei? - His games played log looks pretty good. But he’s priced as the greatest player in baseball history, and the evidence says that he can’t really be a full-time pitcher and hitter anymore (hasn’t pitched 100 innings since 2024). He’s frequently dinged up. Can he still be the greatest player ever if he’s a really, really good DH that sometimes pitches? Do the Dodgers give up on him pitching altogether because they’re so loaded with starters?

How to Invest In Injured Players

Two main things to keep in mind here:

  1. Normally healthy guys with a single injury are fine to chase - think Mahomes, Tatum, Haliburton, etc.

  2. You have to get in earlier than you used to. For example, Haliburton’s Silver Prizm PSA 10 prices took a big dip after his injury in the finals, but then started increasing drastically WAY before he was even coming back. Stars with a long injury timeline require purchasing early and sitting on it:

Tatum’s pricing return wasn’t quite as dramatic, but it did crescendo with his return… and then promptly fell when they got bounced from the playoffs.

I suspect once Haliburton’s back on the court that his pricing will drop. Even if he plays stellar, he can’t replicate the magical Finals run in October games. Plus, he’s not a traditional “clear out and let him score 28 points” guy, which limits his top-end potential.

My Plea to You

To upgrade your flipping, do whatever you can to limit your risk. I think about downside just as much as upside when I’m buying cards.

You can find great cards to flip, so don’t settle or compromise. Look harder, do more research. It’s okay to spend an hour on eBay and not buy any cards. If it’s not a home run, don’t buy it - especially when you’re starting out.

And We’re Done!

Before you go: Here’s how I can help…

1) Casual Flipper Bootcamp - 6 live training sessions designed to teach you to be a profitable sports card flipper. Join the waiting list today.

2) HCL Investor - My best investment plays each week, including cards, pricing, timeline windows, and more. Delivered every Saturday.

3) Cards to Cash - My entire investing strategy playbook, available on Amazon. It currently has 95+ reviews with a 4.8 rating.