Transcript 0:00 Chapter six, timing. Buy quiet, sell loud. I mentioned earlier that I paid $150 for a 1997-98 Topps Finest PSA 9 Tim Duncan. 0:10 If you pull up that card's price history on Card Ladder, you'll see a long line of sales bouncing around, and then one sale sitting way up at the very top of the chart, higher than anything before or after it. 0:21 That's mine. I bought the single highest sale in that card's history because I listened to an influencer on a podcast. Within a year, the same card was selling for around $15. I still have it. 0:32 Every so often I pull up the chart, look at my little dot sitting at the peak, and smile. It has lately moved in my favor, but I'd still like to joke that my plan was a 10-year flip to break even. 0:42 My problem was deciding that Tim Duncan was one of the greatest ever and should go up over time, and I bought at current prices. I had no clue I was buying at all-time highs. I didn't even have Card Ladder at the time. 0:53 I just paid around, okay, slightly more than, the recent comps. It seems obvious now, but the lesson learned is to make sure you're not buying at all-time highs. Reading the chart. 1:04 The best way to understand price movement is to study charts, and you can study them without having to buy any cards. Here's how I practice. 1:11 I pull up a flagship rookie with a lot of sales, like a prism or Topps Chrome rookie of a big-name player. 1:17 Then I look at every spot where the price jumped or dropped, and ask myself one question, why did it move right there? Once you're able to explain these bumps on the chart, you start seeing these patterns over and over. 1:28 And once you see the patterns, you can spot them before they happen. For example, take Luka's PSA 10 prism chart. There are five big moves on it. In order, here's what happened at each one. 1:39 One, he was traded to the Lakers. Two, he got bounced from the playoffs. Three, he was on a men's health cover about how in shape he was. Four, the Lakers made a big run near the end of the season. 1:50 And five, he got injured and then bounced from the playoffs again. Note, if I'm unable to explain why pricing has dropped or increased, I'll usually stay away. I invest in predictability. 2:01 A few rules for using price charts to flip cards. Buy after a decrease with a reason it should turn around. Buy a card that's been sliding for a real and temporary reason rather than chase one that already spiked. 2:13 One outlier sale doesn't redraw the line. Every chart has a random sale way above or below the rest. Ignore it. Look at where most of the sales are landing. Find the ceiling and the floor. 2:24 On an established player, prices often bounce between a high and a low over a year or two. Buy near the floor, sell near the ceiling. And this only works on proven players. 2:33 A rookie with three months of sales doesn't have enough history to read yet. For them, you'll have to lean more on your future projections rather than price history. 2:42 If I'd done any of this before buying that Duncan card, I would have seen I was paying a price nobody had ever paid before. That's a pretty big clue to run the other direction. Prices peak before the big moment. 2:54 Here's a pattern that trips up almost everyone. You'd think a player's cards would jump right after he wins MVP, makes the All-Star team, or wins a championship. Usually, they don't. 3:04 Price generally climbs on the way to the big moment. By the time it actually happens, the price has already baked it in. Then the excitement fades, and so does the price. 3:13 I've watched this happen with championship runs again and again. Prices on the stars climb all through the playoffs, peak somewhere before the title is won, and then slide back down once the parade is over. 3:23 I have a dozen screenshotted examples of this on my computer, but I'll just share a few here so you don't fall asleep. Take Shai Gilgeous-Alexander's PSA 10 prism chart. 3:32 Both times he was announced as MVP, his price dropped right after. Or look at Sam Darnold. His PSA 10 prism peaked right when he won the Super Bowl, and the very next day, it started dropping. So my rule is simple. 3:44 Sell before the big moment, not after. If I'm holding a card of a player headed for an award or a title, I'm usually listing it while the hype is building. Most people buy on the news before they think. 3:55 A player gets traded to a big market team. Within hours, people are buying his cards like crazy. Then a week or two later, things calm down. 4:03 People realize he's the same player in a different jersey, and the price drifts back down. This happens all the time with trades, big free agent signings, and viral highlight plays. 4:13 The hobby reacts first and thinks later. Even minor league call-ups have price spikes that settle back down. When big news hits, I try to do the opposite. 4:21 I wait, watch, and ask whether the news actually changes how good this player is or how much people will want his cards a year from now. Usually, it doesn't. 4:29 And if it does, the card will still be there next week, probably at a better price. Wait at least three months after a release. When a new card set comes out, prices start high. 4:39 Everyone wants the shiny new rookies, and there aren't many copies out there yet. Then people keep opening boxes. More and more copies hit eBay, and prices slide. It happens with every release. 4:50 The rule of thumb is not to buy cards from a new set until at least three months after it comes out. By then, the early excitement has worn off, the supply has caught up, and I can see what a card is really worth. 5:01 Sometimes you'll need to wait more than three months. Wemby prism PSA 10s dropped for nine months after they started hitting the market. That's what happens when flagship rookies for generational prospects come out. 5:12 Waiting feels boring, but it's one of the easiest ways to avoid overpaying. The LaMelo lesson. 5:18 Back when I was still pretty new to flipping, I bought a LaMelo Ball prism draft picks card for $25 right after it was released. LaMelo was everywhere. 5:26 He had a huge following, a famous family, and everyone was talking about how good he was going to be. I figured I was getting in early. Within a few months, that card was worth about a dollar. 5:36 I made two obvious mistakes. First, I bought the peak, I bought at the peak of his hype right after release. I thought that he's going to be good and people are talking about him was enough to go buy him. 5:48 Boy, was I wrong. Second, it was a non-pro uniform. On this card, he's wearing a black T-shirt with no logos, so he could have just been playing in an open gym. 5:57 When licensed pro uni cards come out, everything else tanks in value. Honestly, it was probably worth that $25 lesson at the time, but I'm hoping that by sharing this, you can avoid making this mistake altogether. 6:09 When timing goes right. Now for a happier story. When Jayson Tatum tore his Achilles, prices dropped as you'd expect. That's not the happy part. 6:18 Knowing we wouldn't get to see him on the court for a while is a great way for the hobby to lose interest. During his recovery, I bought a Rockstars card for $70. My reasons were pretty simple. 6:28 He was a superstar in his prime. The injury was serious, but it shouldn't end his career. The price was low because people were scared, and the Celtics should still be a wins machine. 6:37 Nothing had actually changed about how good he was. I sent the card to PSA, and it came back a 10. 6:43 When Tatum came back and started looking like Tatum again, or, or at least close to it, the buzz came right back with him. That's when I sold for $295, netting about $150 after all costs. 6:54 But buy when price is low and there are two or three reasons prices will come back up. Put that on my tombstone. 7:00 It sounds drop-dead obvious, but there's a reason I've already said it like five times, because most people don't do it. Chapter six in a nutshell. 7:09 Buy when a player isn't being talked about and sell when the hype is back. Learn to read a price chart by asking why the price moved at every bump. One outlier sale doesn't redraw the line. 7:19 Look for the ceiling and the floor on proven players. Prices usually peak before the big moment, like an MVP, an All-Star nod, or a title. Sell before it happens. Most people buy on the news before they think. 7:31 Wait a week and see if the news really matters. And wait at least three months after a new set comes out before buying from it.